Pacioli's printer imitated the shorthand of medieval scribes. These marks are not accents: each one means “some letters left out here”, so we have to figure out what letters and these "abbreviations" are indistinct so can be confused one with another as well as different versions being used for the same thing; if we ever find an original of the handwritten document it will be very helpful to see what the scribe actually wrote. Each example below is a real word cut from the book, with how it reads. Meanings are standard medieval abbreviation practice, as understood by the project's AI models; they have not yet been checked against a human edition.
| sign | in the print | what you see | what it means | reads as | times in Treatise XI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ⁊c̃ | a figure like a 7, then a small c with a mark above it | the Roman shorthand sign for et (“and”) plus c | et cetera, our “etc.” | 375 | |
| tilde on a vowel | a small wavy line above a vowel (õ ã ẽ) | a missing n or m | commo = “as, how” (modern come) | 73 | |
| tanti = “so many” | 10 | ||||
| tempo = “time” | 9 | ||||
| facende = “business affairs” (modern faccende) | 18 | ||||
| danno = “loss” | 17 | ||||
| q̃ | a q with a tilde | q + a missing ue (or ui) | questo = “this” | 50 | |
| quello = “that” | 37 | ||||
| tilde on a consonant | a tilde above a consonant at the end of a word | the word is cut short | ducati = “ducats” (the coin) | 20 | |
| raised letter | a small letter raised beside the word | the end of a longer word | capitolo = “chapter” | 15 | |
| a hooked sign like a raised 9 after a number | marks an ordinal | xiᵗʰ = “11th” (here: Tractatus xi, Treatise 11) | 10 | ||
| ꝑ | a p with a stroke through its tail | per / par | perche = “because, why” | 1 | |
| ꝓ | a p with a curl on its tail | pro | prompto = “ready, prompt” (modern pronto) | ||
| p̃ | a p with a tilde above it | pre | pregio = “worth, value” | ||
| presso = “near, by” | |||||
| ꝛ round r | a curved letter like a 2, after b, d, h, o, p | just the letter r in a different shape (not an abbreviation) | libro = “book” | ||
| ordine = “order” | |||||
| ſ long s | a tall s with no crossbar, looking like an f without its bar | just the letter s | scripture = “writings, records” |
| sign | in the print | what you see | what it means | reads as |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ꝓ | a p with a small curl on its tail | pro | prompto = “ready, prompt” (modern pronto) | |
| p̃ | a p with a tilde above it | pre | pregio = “worth, value” | |
| (the same sign) | pre | presso = “near, by” | ||
| ꝝ | a sign for the Latin ending -rum | almost never seen in Treatise XI, so no example is shown | ||
| ꝫ | a sign for -et or -ue | also very rare here, so no example is shown | ||
The Gothic capitals are very ornate, and C and E look almost the same. Here are a C (Chiamando) and an E (E) from the same page:
Also note that the sign ꝗ is just another form of q̃.